25 Jews on what being Jewish means in the 21st Century
“Two Jews, three opinions” goes the adage and yet, in 2019, it feels as though Jewish people are being treated as a monolith with a shared opinion on everything. Anyone who has ever attended a Shabbat dinner will know how absurd such a notion truly is.
Israel, The Labour Party, the pronunciation of bagel – it’s all up for grabs. After the success of The Good Immigrant, a collection of essays exploring what it means to be black, Asian and minority ethnic in this country, The Jewish Question asks writers, academics and entertainers one simple question that no two Jews could or would ever answer the same way: what does being Jewish mean to you?
There are cultural Jews, Zionist Jews, queer Jews, orthodox Jews, good Jews and, according to at least one hit West End play, bad Jews. By asking contributors including Charlotte Mendelson, Jonathan Freedland, Devorah Baum, Matt Greene, Phoebe Roy, Emma Forrest, Zoe Margolis, Josh Howie, Roberta Klimt, Peter Mehlman, Patrick Marber, Benjamin Dreyer, Michael Rosen, Andy Nyman, Eva Wiseman, AD Miller, Sandra Newman, Rabbi Laura Janner-Klausner, Alex Edelman, Jon Lansman, Dr. Aviah Sarah Day, Lee Kern and Leslie Brent for an essay on what being Jewish means to them, this book should make the diversity of modern Jewry clear for all to see.
At a time when anti-Semitism is back in the news and the grim spectre of Holocaust denial is finding its way back onto the front pages, this collection should educate, entertain and provoke during a period when this country’s Jews are in the familiar position of feeling like neither insiders nor outsiders but observers and chroniclers hiding in plain sight.
I have always considered myself Jewish with an emphasis on the ish. As recently as ten years ago, the idea of my putting this book together would have been unthinkable. I go to synagogue a couple of times a year, avoid pork largely on superstitious grounds and am not sufficiently convinced of God’s existence to opt for a dash in place of the O. Kate, my lapsed Catholic wife, is adamant that we have a Christmas tree in the house every December for our son and this makes me uncomfortable but I insisted we have his foreskin removed so that probably makes us even.
It looks like Darren Richman has not made any updates yet. Check back soon!
These people are helping to fund The Jewish Question.